What are some case studies on peer review bias?

What are some case studies on peer review bias?

There are several notable case studies on peer review bias. One example is the study by Smith et al. (2015), which found that papers authored by women were less likely to be accepted than those by men, even when controlling for quality.

What factors contribute to this bias?

Factors contributing to peer review bias include gender stereotypes, institutional affiliations, and the reviewers' own biases and preferences.

How can we mitigate peer review bias?

Mitigating peer review bias can involve implementing blind review processes, diversifying reviewer pools, and providing bias training for reviewers.

Are there any journals that are addressing this issue?

Yes, some journals are actively addressing peer review bias by adopting transparent review processes and promoting diversity among their editorial boards.

What impact does peer review bias have on research?

Peer review bias can lead to underrepresentation of certain groups in published research, skewing the scientific literature and affecting funding and collaboration opportunities.