What are some effective strategies for ensuring fair peer review?

What are some effective strategies for ensuring fair peer review?

To ensure fair peer review, consider implementing double-blind reviews, clear guidelines for reviewers, and diverse reviewer pools.

How does double-blind review work?

In double-blind review, both the authors and reviewers remain anonymous to each other, reducing bias.

What guidelines should be provided to reviewers?

Guidelines should include criteria for evaluation, expectations for feedback, and timelines for review completion.

How can we encourage more diverse reviewers?

Encouraging diverse reviewers can be achieved by actively seeking out underrepresented scholars and providing incentives.

What are the common biases in peer review?

Common biases include gender bias, affiliation bias, and confirmation bias, which can affect the review process.